He did not dispute owing his condo fees, only the interest and the penalties. Over an amount that initially hovered around $6,600, a Gatineau condo owner stopped paying altogether, filed proceeding after proceeding, and went after lawyers, court clerks and judges. The outcome: the Court of Québec ordered the forced sale of his unit, awarded $20,000 in damages against him and declared him a vexatious litigant. A lesson in proportionality that goes well beyond the world of condominiums.
People sometimes say a bad settlement beats a good lawsuit. The case of Syndicat des copropriétaires de la Terrasse Chavoin c. Hasan Mohamad (2026 QCCQ 4663), decided on September 8, 2026 by Judge Stéphane D. Tremblay of the Court of Québec, Civil Division, district of Gatineau, is a striking illustration of what happens when you do exactly the opposite: turn a modest disagreement into trench warfare.
The facts: a dispute over interest, then no more payments
The co-owner stopped paying his common expenses in October 2022. He did not deny owing them: he admitted the principal, which stood at $15,129 for the period from October 2022 to March 2025 and at $22,109 by the time of trial. What he contested was the interest and late fees. In his view, the syndicate (in Quebec, the legal entity made up of all co-owners that manages the building) could not claim them without first sending him the notice provided for in section 148 of the declaration of co-ownership. When the syndicate was claiming $21,745.42, the real financial stake was therefore limited to $6,616.42.
In September 2024, the syndicate registered two legal hypothecs (a Quebec security right comparable to a lien) against the unit: one for the unpaid common expenses, the other securing a judgment of the Small Claims Division, rendered by default against the co-owner in another matter, ordering him to pay $4,574.52 plus costs and interest. In December 2024, it registered prior notices of the exercise of its hypothecary rights, then asked the court to order the forced surrender and sale of the unit, and to declare the co-owner an abusive and vexatious litigant.
At trial, the syndicate actually gave up part of its claim: rather than interest of 2% per month compounded (an effective annual rate of 26.82%), it limited itself to simple interest at 24% per year. Its claim for common expenses thus dropped from $39,149.42 to $30,657.28 as of March 13, 2026.
Interest and penalties: read the whole declaration of co-ownership
The declaration of co-ownership is the contract that binds all co-owners from the moment they buy their unit. When its terms are clear, the court simply applies them. Here, the judge saw no ambiguity.
To understand why, you need to know what “benefit of the term” means. Common expenses are set for the year but payable in monthly instalments: that schedule is the “term” granted to the co-owner. Section 148 of the declaration allows the board of directors, if it so chooses, to strip a defaulting co-owner of that benefit and demand the balance of the entire annual contribution at once. Only in that case is a written notice required. The syndicate never exercised that option: it kept claiming the monthly instalments one at a time.
Interest, for its part, flows from a different clause, section 149, under which all arrears bear interest from the date they become payable, without prior notice. The same goes for the $25-per-month late fee, a penalty clause that applies after a ten-day grace period. The judge therefore granted interest at 24% per year on each late instalment, as well as $1,055 in late fees (41 monthly defaults) and an NSF cheque charge. He also rejected the co-owner’s criticism of the calculation: each unpaid instalment generates its own simple interest, with no double counting and no “interest on interest.”
You cannot retry a case you have already lost
The co-owner devoted much of his defence to attacking the small claims judgment secured by the second hypothec, alleging among other things breaches of procedural fairness. But he had already tried everything: an application to revoke the judgment, an application for judicial review, an appeal, a request to stay execution and an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, all dismissed. He even asked the Supreme Court to reconsider its refusal, although its own rules reserve that possibility for extremely rare circumstances.
Judge Tremblay was categorical: he was not sitting in appeal or review of those decisions. The judgment is enforceable and the hypothec can take effect. Using a forced-surrender proceeding to relitigate a dispute already decided all the way to the Supreme Court amounted, in his view, to recklessness.
Forced surrender and sale: how a syndicate can have a unit sold
Quebec’s Civil Code grants the condo syndicate a legal hypothec on the unit of a co-owner who has been in default for more than thirty days in paying their share of common expenses or contributions to the contingency fund. A creditor who obtains a judgment may also register a legal hypothec on the debtor’s property. These hypothecs are not symbolic: as a last resort, they allow the property to be sold.
The process is closely regulated. The creditor must first register a prior notice of the exercise of its hypothecary right. For immovable property (real estate), the debtor then has 60 days to pay the debt. Once that period has expired, the creditor may demand that the debtor “surrender” the property, meaning hand over possession, and ask the court to order a sale under judicial authority.
In this case, nothing was paid within the 60 days. Along the way, the judge confirmed that service of the notices by a bailiff, slipped in a sealed envelope under the unit’s door after two unsuccessful attempts, was valid, all the more so since the co-owner was able to defend himself fully. He therefore ordered the co-owner to surrender the unit within five days of service of the judgment, and ordered its sale by private agreement by a designated bailiff, at a price not lower than the municipal assessment of $198,400 unless the court orders otherwise. The judgment is enforceable notwithstanding any appeal.
Abuse of procedure: when defending yourself becomes a fault
Article 51 of Quebec’s Code of Civil Procedure allows the courts to declare abusive a proceeding that is clearly unfounded, frivolous or dilatory, vexatious or quarrelsome behaviour, or the excessive or unreasonable use of procedure. The threshold is high, and the judge takes care to say so: defending a mistaken interpretation of the declaration of co-ownership is not a fault. Losing is not abusing.
What tipped the scales was the escalation. Alongside the dispute, the co-owner sued, among others, the syndicate’s lawyer and another legal professional involved in registering the hypothecs, as well as the registrar of real rights and clerks of the Court of Québec. He filed complaints with the Bar’s syndic against the syndicate’s lawyer and even against the lawyer defending her, brought five motions to recuse the judge, lodged a complaint with the Conseil de la magistrature (the body that hears complaints against provincially appointed judges) and asked that the syndicate’s lawyer be disqualified, accusing her, without basis, of complicity in fraud. At the hearing, he candidly admitted that he submitted his arguments in bulk, leaving it to the judge to sort out which ones had merit.
The judge also stressed that if the dispute had truly been only about the interpretation of section 148, nothing prevented the co-owner from continuing to pay the principal: the dispute would then have been limited to a marginal amount. His written proposals to pay the principal on his own terms were not “real offers” within the meaning of the law, merely settlement proposals that the syndicate had no obligation to accept.
By the time of trial, the syndicate had incurred more than $27,000 in legal fees. It acknowledged that about $7,000 would have been needed in any event to pursue its claim. The judge awarded it the difference, $20,000 in compensatory damages. He declined, however, to add punitive damages, finding that the award and the vexatious litigant order were sufficient to prevent and deter.
The vexatious litigant order: a filter, not a locked door
When the abuse stems from quarrelsome behaviour, article 55 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows the court to bar a person from bringing a claim or filing a proceeding without prior authorization. Case law describes the quarrelsome (or vexatious) litigant through a cluster of indicators: obstinacy, multiple proceedings (often against lawyers, court staff and judges), repeatedly raising the same issues despite failures, arguments bordering on the irrational, grossly inflated claims, filings riddled with personal attacks, and refusal to respect the authority of the courts. Not every trait needs to be present: it is the overall picture that matters.
The judge concluded that the co-owner displayed almost all of them. He noted, among other things, claims of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in a dispute that initially concerned about $6,600, disparaging remarks aimed at the syndicate’s lawyer and at judges, and similar conduct before other courts and on social media. The co-owner was therefore declared a vexatious litigant: he may no longer file any claim or proceeding with the court offices of the Court of Québec without the prior written authorization of the Chief Judge, and the order is entered in the public registry kept for that purpose.
The goal, the judge recalls, is not to deprive a person of the right to go to court, but to subject their filings to a filter that protects the opposing party, judicial resources and the integrity of the system. Note that the order applies to the Court of Québec. The Superior Court and the Court of Appeal keep their own registries and issue their own orders.
Why this case stands out
First, because of the disproportion between the initial stake and the outcome. A disagreement of about $6,600 led to the forced sale of a condo unit, a $20,000 award, legal costs and a lasting restriction on the right to go to court. The moral is simple but worth repeating: you can be wrong without committing a fault, but you cannot make your opponent, and the justice system, pay the price of your refusal to accept that you might be wrong.
That said, some nuance is in order. Access to justice is a fundamental right, and courts show leniency toward people who represent themselves, who are often overwhelmed by complex rules. The judge acknowledges this, while making clear that such latitude is not a free pass. Moreover, questioning an interest rate of 24% per year was not absurd in itself; the syndicate itself reduced its claim by giving up monthly compounding. The problem was not contesting, but how it was done: by stopping all payments and attacking people rather than issues.
Finally, the case is a reminder that participants in the justice system (lawyers, clerks, public officers) are not targets. Suing the opposing party’s lawyer personally for defending their client’s position, or piling up complaints against them, is one of the clearest signs of abusive behaviour.
Key takeaways
For co-owners. If you dispute part of your account, at least pay what you do not dispute. You will limit the dispute, the interest and the costs, and protect your credibility before the court. To stop interest from running on an amount you believe is owed, a mere proposal is not enough: the law provides a specific mechanism of real offers and deposit (articles 1573 and following of the Civil Code of Québec). Also read your declaration of co-ownership in its entirety: its clauses must be read together.
Do not underestimate the syndicate’s legal hypothec. Unpaid fees can ultimately lead to the loss of your unit. If you receive a prior notice of the exercise of a hypothecary right, the 60-day period is critical: consult a lawyer promptly.
For condo syndicates. Document arrears rigorously, apply the declaration as written, and do not hesitate to revise a claim that could be open to criticism, as the syndicate did by giving up compounding. When faced with a co-owner who keeps filing proceedings, articles 51 to 55 of the Code of Civil Procedure make it possible to have the abuse sanctioned and to recover part of the legal fees incurred.
For everyone. Before getting into a legal dispute with a person or a business, you can check Quebec’s public registries of persons found to be quarrelsome. And if you are representing yourself, a one-time legal consultation can keep a legitimate disagreement from turning into a lost cause.
Further reading
See also our columns Unpaid Condo Fees: Two Days of Hearing for Nothing, A Neglected Water Heater and a $76,231 Bill: the Court of Québec’s Vigilance Lesson for Condo Owners and Quebec construction legal hypothec: registered too late, a $230,000 hypothec struck off and $8,000 to pay, as well as the Public registry of persons found to be quarrelsome by the Court of Québec.
This column is published for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Because every situation is unique, you should consult a lawyer for advice tailored to your own case. Feel free to contact Virtulex avocats to discuss your situation.
William Desrochers, Attorney, Virtulex avocats — www.virtulexavocats.com
Reference: Syndicat des copropriétaires de la Terrasse Chavoin c. Hasan Mohamad, 2026 QCCQ 4663, Court of Québec, Civil Division, district of Gatineau, Judge Stéphane D. Tremblay, September 8, 2026 — read the judgment on CanLII (in French).
