Off-plan condo sales, gross versus net area, Quebec’s Consumer Protection Act and price reductions for insufficient area
A few months after moving into her brand-new penthouse, a buyer noticed there was barely enough room to open the fridge door and that her partner kept tripping on a stair. Curious, she pulled out a tape measure. The verdict: the private portion of her unit was noticeably smaller than the area stated in the contract. The other units her family had bought in the same project had the same problem.
In Tsatas c. Devmont W6 inc., 2026 QCCS 3304, Justice Marie-Hélène Dubé of the Quebec Superior Court found on September 9, 2026, that the developer had made misleading representations. The buyers were entitled to a price reduction, but in amounts far lower than they had claimed.
The facts: five units, the same gap
Between 2017 and 2019, members of one family bought five units off-plan in a project in Montreal’s Côte-des-Neiges neighbourhood. The preliminary contracts stated an area in square feet, without specifying whether it was gross or net. In reality, the gap between the advertised area and the private portion ranged from 7.5% to 10.6% depending on the unit.
Gross or net: what’s the difference?
Gross area, the figure on the architect’s plans used to sell units, is measured from the outside face of exterior walls and the middle of shared and corridor walls. It therefore includes wall thickness that is partly common property.
Net area is the private portion only, as measured by a land surveyor and shown on the certificate of location. Roughly speaking, it is the space that is truly yours.
According to the evidence, a gap of about 10% is well known in the industry, and the developer knew the expected gap would fall between 7% and 14%. Yet it never put a number on it, neither when the purchase promises were signed nor at the signing of the deeds of sale, when the exact gap was already known.
Warnings that didn’t inform
The developer argued it had done everything required: the documents explained in detail that architectural areas are measured from the outside face of walls, that cadastral measurements are always smaller, and an addendum clause even stated that the buyer was purchasing “without regard to the area and content.” Sales representatives had also explained verbally that there would be a difference.
The judge was not persuaded. Under Quebec’s Consumer Protection Act, whether a representation is misleading is assessed from the standpoint of a credulous and inexperienced consumer. These technical explanations did not make it possible to understand the concrete effect on the private portion. Even the sales representative did not know the size of the gap he was supposed to explain. The buyers, all highly educated, understood the concepts but expected a minimal difference, in the range of 2% to 3%.
For the judge, instead of informing the buyers, these explanations diverted their attention to technical details that seemed credible but conveyed little. The result:
- misleading representations, even though they were not false (s. 219 of the Act);
- failure to mention an important fact, namely the gap between gross and net area (s. 228).
A practice prohibited by the Act amounts to fraud (in civil law terms, “dol”), a deception that vitiates consent. The law then presumes that, had they known, consumers would not have paid as high a price (s. 253), and the developer failed to rebut that presumption. As for the “without regard to the area” clause, its meaning was not self-evident, since even the developer’s lawyer admitted it did not allow the developer to deliver any area whatsoever.
The judge noted, however, that there was no false dimension in the strict sense: the gross areas delivered matched those promised.
Compensation… revised downward
The buyers claimed more than $500,000 in total, including $332,000 for the penthouse. The court awarded much less, for several reasons:
- The wrong valuation date: the buyers’ expert valued the missing area as of March 2021, whereas the relevant date is when the purchase promises were signed. Her report also overvalued the penthouse.
- A small difference had been accepted: the judge deducted about 3% from the gap, since the buyers expected a slight difference.
- The price covered more than floor space: parking, storage lockers, appliances, a rent guarantee, shared amenities, a volume discount and, for the penthouse, custom design work.
Relying mainly on a net price per square foot agreed between the experts during trial, the judge granted price reductions ranging from $1,639 to $38,095 per unit, about $88,000 in total. She dismissed the developer’s counterclaim accusing the buyers of abuse of process: their claims were inflated and some of their positions shifted, but their lawsuit was well founded. The buyers must, however, bear the cost of the expert reports found to be of no use.
Why this case matters
The gaps here are more modest than in most earlier decisions, which often involved discrepancies above 10%. The court nonetheless confirms that a gap of 7.5% to 10.6% is an important fact that must be clearly disclosed. The judge also expressly departed from a 2017 Court of Québec decision (Mogdad) holding that a gap consistent with industry standards was not a problem. The case law debate is therefore not entirely settled.
The case also sends a message to buyers: being right in principle does not guarantee generous compensation. A poorly valued claim can be costly in expert fees.
Key takeaways
- Before signing an off-plan purchase promise, ask in writing for the estimated net area of the private portion, or the expected percentage gap from the gross area.
- Compare the area on the certificate of location (often in square metres) with the one in the preliminary contract (often in square feet) before signing the deed of sale.
- For developers: a technical explanation is not enough. State the expected gap in understandable numbers; it is the best protection against a lawsuit.
- A “without regard to the area” clause is not an absolute shield where consent was obtained through a misleading practice.
- If you sue, have the missing area valued as of the purchase promise date and account for everything the price included.
Further reading
- Buying Land You Can’t Build On: The Sale Is Cancelled, but Who Pays?
- Cancelling a contract in Quebec: the real cooling-off periods
- Unpaid condo fees: a $6,600 dispute over interest ends in the forced sale of the unit
This column is published for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Because every situation is unique, you should consult a lawyer for advice tailored to your own case. Feel free to contact Virtulex avocats to discuss your situation.
William Desrochers, Attorney, Virtulex avocats — www.virtulexavocats.com
Reference: Tsatas c. Devmont W6 inc., 2026 QCCS 3304 (Quebec Superior Court, September 9, 2026) — full text on CanLII (French)
