Me Desrochers : 819 743-2955  |  Me Roy : 819 208-6022 info@virtulexavocats.com

Some debts never go away, even after a discharge — here is which ones, and what that means for debtors and creditors alike.

Patrick, a mechanic in Gatineau, can’t sleep. Three maxed-out credit cards, a car loan, $14,000 in overdue taxes, a student loan balance that has been hanging around since his CEGEP days (Quebec’s pre-university college system), and unpaid child support for his two children. A coworker told him: “Declare bankruptcy — it wipes everything out and you start fresh.” Patrick books an appointment, relieved. What he doesn’t know yet is that a good part of what is choking him will follow him after his discharge. At the other end, the mother of his children is also wondering whether she has just lost her rights. In both cases, the answer lies in a single provision: section 178 of the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act.

Bankruptcy or consumer proposal: two very different paths

Both procedures fall under the same federal statute and go through a licensed insolvency trustee, a professional licensed by the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. They do not, however, produce the same effects.

Bankruptcy is an assignment of property: the debtor hands their seizable assets over to the trustee, who liquidates them and distributes the proceeds among the creditors.

A consumer proposal is a settlement offer made to creditors: repay part of the debt, or spread it out over a period of no more than five years. It is available only to an individual whose debts, not counting those secured by their principal residence, do not exceed $250,000. Its great advantage: you keep your property.

The common trap: believing a proposal is always the “lesser evil.” It generally lasts longer than a first bankruptcy and leaves a mark on your credit file for several years after the last payment. Bankruptcy, conversely, is shorter, but it costs you your seizable assets. The right choice depends on the numbers, not on gut feeling.

The debts a discharge never wipes out

Section 178 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act lists the debts that survive a discharge order. This is not a punishment: it reflects a public-policy view that certain obligations cannot be shed on the cheap.

The list includes, notably:

  • fines, penalties and restitution orders imposed by a court;
  • court-awarded damages in civil proceedings for bodily harm intentionally inflicted or for sexual assault, including damages for a death resulting from either. The word intentionally is critical: a judgment for injuries caused by mere negligence, on the other hand, is wiped out;
  • support debts and obligations (alimony and child support), as well as those arising from a filiation or support order, or from a support agreement for a spouse, former partner or child living apart from the bankrupt. Patrick’s support arrears will therefore survive in full;
  • debts resulting from fraud, embezzlement, misappropriation or defalcation committed while acting as a trustee or administrator of another person’s property;
  • debts incurred to obtain property or services by false pretences or fraudulent misrepresentation — for example, a false statement of income on a credit application;
  • student loans made or guaranteed under applicable federal or provincial legislation, where the bankruptcy occurs before the end of studies or within seven years afterwards. The same rule applies to apprenticeship loans;
  • interest on all of these amounts.

There is a safety valve for student debt: after five years out of school, the bankrupt can ask the court to exempt the debt from the rule by showing that they acted in good faith and that they are experiencing, and will continue to experience, financial difficulties so serious that they will never be able to repay it. It is a demanding application, granted sparingly.

The common trap, on the creditor’s side: assuming that your claim is one of those that survive. It is up to the creditor to show that the debt falls into one of the categories in section 178. The court looks at the true nature of the debt and may look beyond the wording of a judgment, but a judgment drafted in vague terms makes that proof considerably harder. The wording of the conclusions, obtained well before the bankruptcy, often makes all the difference.

What happens to your property

Property that provincial law declares exempt from seizure is beyond the trustee’s reach. In Quebec, the Code of Civil Procedure exempts from seizure, among other things, the movable property furnishing the principal residence that serves the household’s use and is necessary to it, up to a market value of $7,000 as determined by the bailiff, as well as the tools necessary for the debtor’s personal practice of their occupation (article 694). The passenger vehicle needed to maintain the debtor’s employment income, or for the subsistence, care or education of the debtor and their dependants, is also protected (article 695).

For the principal residence, Quebec grants no blanket exemption, but a building serving as the principal residence may be seized only for a support debt or a debt of at least $20,000 (article 700 C.C.P.). In practice, what matters in a bankruptcy is equity — the net value after mortgages. If there is little or none, the home can often be kept; if there is a lot, the bankrupt will have to buy it back from the trustee or watch it be sold.

RRSPs and pension plans are in principle protected, except for contributions made in the twelve months before the bankruptcy, which the trustee can recover. The common trap: cashing in your RRSP before consulting anyone, to pay creditors. You then liquidate a protected asset to settle a debt that would have been wiped out anyway.

The stay of proceedings, the timeline and objections

As soon as the file is opened, the law imposes a stay of proceedings: ordinary creditors can no longer sue, seize or enforce a judgment. Be careful, though — it doesn’t cover everything: secured creditors keep their remedies against their collateral, and support proceedings follow their own rules.

The discharge of an individual is in principle automatic. For a first bankruptcy, it occurs after nine months, or after twenty-one months if the bankrupt had to make payments on surplus income — the portion of their income that exceeds the thresholds set by the Superintendent. For a second bankruptcy, the periods become twenty-four and thirty-six months.

This automatic discharge falls away if the Superintendent, the trustee or a creditor files a reasoned notice of opposition before the scheduled discharge date. The trustee must then apply to the court for a hearing. A creditor who notices undeclared assets, a lifestyle inconsistent with declared income, or debts taken on with no hope of repayment holds real leverage here — one that is too rarely used.

Key takeaways

  1. Bankruptcy does not wipe out support payments and their arrears, fines and restitution orders, debts arising from fraud or misrepresentation, or damages for bodily harm intentionally inflicted or for sexual assault.
  2. A student loan is wiped out only if the bankruptcy occurs more than seven years after the end of studies; after five years, an application to the court remains possible in cases of good faith and lasting hardship.
  3. Compare bankruptcy and a consumer proposal before choosing: a proposal, available up to $250,000 of debt excluding the mortgage on your residence, lets you keep your property.
  4. Don’t liquidate anything — least of all an RRSP — before getting advice: you could sacrifice a protected asset for a debt that was about to disappear.
  5. As a creditor, have your conclusions drafted in precise terms (fraud, misrepresentation, intentional act): that wording will make it much easier to prove that your claim survives.
  6. As a creditor, watch for the discharge: you can oppose it, in writing and with reasons, before the scheduled date.

Further reading


This column is published for general legal information purposes and reflects the state of the law as at the date it was written. It does not constitute legal advice. Because every situation is unique, you should consult a lawyer for advice tailored to your own case. Feel free to contact Virtulex avocats to discuss your situation.

William Desrochers, Attorney, Virtulex avocats — www.virtulexavocats.com