Me Desrochers : 819 743-2955  |  Me Roy : 819 208-6022 info@virtulexavocats.com

A father has two children from two different relationships. In the first case, a judge ordered a psychosocial assessment of his parenting abilities. In the second, the mother wants to use it. The father objects: the report is confidential. The Superior Court agrees with him in principle, but allows the report to be filed nonetheless. A decision that shows how courts weigh a parent’s privacy against the safety of a young child.

The psychosocial assessment is one of the most important tools in family law. When a dispute concerns parenting time, an expert (often a psychologist or a social worker) meets with the parents and the children, observes family relationships and makes recommendations to the court. Parents often open up completely, assuming that what they confide will be used only in that case. The judgment Droit de la famille — 261536 (2026 QCCS 3672), rendered on September 16, 2026, by the Honourable Jérôme Frappier of the Superior Court of Québec (district of Saint-Hyacinthe), examines what happens when such a report is invoked in another dispute.

The facts: two cases, one father

The parties are the parents of a three-year-old child. They separated in November 2024, in a context of family violence. A safeguard order (an interim order made while the case is pending) issued in May 2025 refers to the mother’s allegations that the father slapped the child on the mouth in March 2025, which led to the final breakup. The judge then found that, despite conflicting evidence, the mother had proven on a balance of probabilities the father’s violence and impulsiveness, evidence corroborated by the sworn statement of his former partner. He also noted the involvement of youth protection services (the DPJ) and the fact that the father had dropped out of therapy on violence and impulsiveness after a few sessions, believing he did not need it. The court granted the vast majority of parenting time to the mother, gave the father supervised access and prohibited him from communicating with the mother and the child. In September 2026, Justice Frappier found that the evidence of the father’s violence still met the balance of probabilities standard.

The father has an eight-year-old daughter from a previous relationship. In that first case, heard in the district of Bedford, a judge ordered a psychosocial assessment in June 2025 dealing in particular with his parenting abilities. The mother of the younger child asks for permission to file that report in her own case, solely regarding the father’s parenting abilities and the violent behaviour he is accused of. The father objects: the report is confidential, the process was unfair to him, and the two mothers of his children are allegedly joining forces against him. He flatly denies all allegations of violence.

A confidential document, protected by law

In family matters, access to court records is restricted (article 16 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.C.P.)). Only the parties, their representatives and lawyers, persons designated by law and persons authorized by the court may consult the documents. A psychosocial assessment report also contains highly personal information about the people assessed.

The court does not know whether, or how, the mother obtained the report. It points out that she should have, or had to, first obtain the Court’s permission by showing a legitimate interest. Relying on a recent Court of Appeal ruling (D.S. c. M.G.), the judge concludes that obtaining the report infringes the father’s fundamental rights, as he could reasonably expect it to remain confidential.

An invasion of privacy does not automatically lead to exclusion

This is where the reasoning becomes interesting. Under article 2858 of the Civil Code of Québec (C.C.Q.), the court must reject evidence obtained in violation of fundamental rights only if its use would tend to bring the administration of justice into disrepute. Both conditions must be met. The judge must therefore weigh the seriousness of the violation against what is at stake in the case. The Court of Appeal reiterates that the search for truth remains the paramount objective of the rules governing the admissibility of evidence.

Following the Court of Appeal, the judge acknowledges the seriousness of the infringement: using evidence obtained in this way in a separate proceeding could undermine families’ confidence in the courts’ ability to protect their privacy. But the stakes here are high. At issue are the safety and protection of a three-year-old child, and the principle of the child’s best interests, which “transcends” all decisions about custody, must guide the balancing exercise (our translation).

The judge distinguishes a 2001 case in which the court refused to allow an assessment prepared in another family dispute to be filed: the report was invoked there to show the in-laws’ beliefs and behaviour amounting to parental alienation, but it was not essential, since that could be shown through direct evidence. The situation is different here. The court is at the safeguard stage and must make an interim decision that will have a direct effect on the child’s life. The allegations of violence amply justify ordering a new assessment, but it will take about ten months to obtain. Given the urgency, the judge concludes that excluding the report would bring the administration of justice into greater disrepute than admitting it.

Important safeguards

The permission is not a blank cheque. The court strictly limits how the report may be used:

  • only the sections dealing with the father’s parenting abilities and the presence of family violence may be used; everything concerning the other child and the other mother must be redacted, that is, blacked out;
  • the report will be filed under seal, to preserve its confidentiality;
  • the author of the report must attend the trial to be examined, solely on the points relevant to this case, and the father will have all the latitude he needs to cross-examine the expert and to nuance or put the conclusions in context.

The court also orders a new psychosocial assessment in the present case.

Why this decision stands out

It illustrates a real tension in family law. On the one hand, the effectiveness of psychosocial assessments depends on the candour of the people being assessed. If parents fear that what they confide will follow them from one case to another, they may become more guarded, which would weaken the assessments. That is the strongest argument for strict protection; the 2001 decision cited by the judge in fact stressed the trust parents place in the expert and in professional secrecy.

On the other hand, it would be hard to accept that a court should deprive itself of a professional assessment already completed, dealing precisely with the abilities of a parent suspected of violence, while a three-year-old child awaits a decision and the new assessment will not be ready for about ten months. Justice Frappier rules in favour of the child, but limits the infringement to what is strictly necessary.

The judgment leaves open a question that could resurface: does the mother have the report and, if so, how did she get it? The court does not know. In another context, for example if the document had been obtained in a more clearly unlawful way, or if the stakes were less pressing, the balance could tip the other way.

Key takeaways

Do not file a confidential document without permission. A psychosocial assessment or any other document from a family case to which you are not a party cannot be filed freely: access to these records is restricted, and you must obtain the court’s permission by showing a legitimate interest.

The child’s best interests carry great weight. When a child’s safety is at stake, courts are prepared to admit evidence they would otherwise exclude, subject to safeguards.

What you tell the expert can have consequences. A psychosocial assessment is confidential, but that confidentiality is not absolute. In our view, it is better to be honest and cooperate: in this case, dropping out of recommended therapy and flatly denying the facts were among the factors noted by the court.

Plan for delays. A psychosocial assessment can take many months to obtain (about ten months in this case). Where there is violence, it is important to act quickly and to present solid evidence from the outset, particularly by sworn statement.

Further reading

See also our columns Custody or parenting time: what the new words really changed, Urgent matters in family law and what weight a child’s opinion carries before the court.


This column is published for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Because every situation is unique, you should consult a lawyer for advice tailored to your own case. Feel free to contact Virtulex avocats to discuss your situation.

William Desrochers, Attorney, Virtulex avocats — www.virtulexavocats.com

Reference: Droit de la famille — 261536, 2026 QCCS 3672, Superior Court of Québec, district of Saint-Hyacinthe, the Honourable Jérôme Frappier, J.S.C., September 16, 2026 — read the judgment on CanLII (in French).

Other decision mentioned: D.S. c. M.G., 2026 QCCA 1156 (cited by the court).