A few weeks before the wedding, he loses his job. Worried, she insists on a marriage contract providing for separation as to property. For years, she criticizes him for not earning enough. At the divorce, she asks that the family patrimony be divided unequally in her favour. The Superior Court refuses and orders her to pay him more than $100,000. A decision that serves as a reminder that a separation as to property contract offers no shelter from the family patrimony, and that a modest income is not a fault.
Many couples believe that a marriage contract providing for separation as to property fully protects their assets in the event of a divorce. That is not accurate. In Québec, the family patrimony applies to every married couple, whatever their matrimonial regime (the set of rules governing the spouses’ property during and after the marriage). And the equal division of that patrimony can be set aside only in exceptional cases. The judgment in Droit de la famille — 261532 (2026 QCCS 3670), rendered on September 30, 2026 by the Honourable Stéphane Lacoste of the Superior Court (District of Montréal), offers a concrete illustration.
The facts: a marriage overshadowed by financial worry
The parties met in 1999 and decided to marry in July 2003. On June 18, 2003, he learned that he had been dismissed from a federal government job. Concerned about having to support an unemployed husband, she asked for a marriage contract providing for separation as to property to protect her assets. He agreed. The contract was signed on July 11, 2003, and the wedding took place on July 19.
He challenged his dismissal in court, at his own expense; a settlement was reached in 2007. In the meantime, he received employment insurance benefits, then began training as a financial planner, which required him to work for a financial firm where he was paid on commission only and earned a modest income. She pressed him to earn more and, in 2007, threatened divorce if he did not change jobs. In 2008, he joined a major bank, where he still works. His income there rose steadily until it exceeded hers from 2012 onward.
During their life together, the couple lived on the ground floor of a building that she owned in undivided co-ownership, half and half, with her mother, who lived upstairs. He paid her a monthly contribution that she set herself and called “rent”: $300 at first, reduced to $200 after his dismissal. He also paid half the electricity, the cable and Internet, and a good share of the groceries. Between 2003 and 2007, he drained almost all of his RRSPs to make ends meet and pay his share. The parties separated on May 31, 2015. They have no children. Divorce proceedings were brought in 2019, and again in 2024.
The family patrimony, even under separation as to property
The family patrimony is a set of property whose value is, in principle, divided equally between the spouses when the marriage ends, regardless of which one owns it. It includes, among other things, the family residences, the furniture in them, the vehicles used by the family and the rights accrued during the marriage under pension plans, including RRSPs, as well as earnings registered with the Québec Pension Plan. Spouses cannot waive it in advance, even in a marriage contract.
A separation as to property contract therefore has a limited effect: it prevents the division of other property (non-registered investment accounts, a business, buildings that are not used as a family residence, etc.), but it does not affect the family patrimony. Note that property received by succession (inheritance) or by gift is excluded from it, and that a compensatory allowance (a claim by a spouse who contributed to enriching the other’s patrimony) remains possible despite separation as to property.
Unequal division: an exception reserved for economic fault
Article 422 of the Civil Code of Québec (C.C.Q.) allows the court to depart from equal division where it would result in an injustice, considering in particular the brevity of the marriage, the waste of property by one spouse, or that spouse’s bad faith. The Supreme Court of Canada has specified that the circumstances relied on must relate to the success or failure of the spouses’ economic partnership: it must be shown that one spouse breached the obligation to contribute to building and maintaining the family patrimony.
Justice Lacoste also notes that spouses contribute towards the expenses of the marriage “in proportion to their respective means” (article 396 C.C.Q.), and that this contribution may take the form of activities within the home. The law imposes no model of what a couple should look like, nor any joint account. An unequal contribution may be a foreseeable consequence of marriage; only a clear economic fault, in exceptional cases, justifies an unequal division.
None of her criticisms holds up
She accused him of a lack of ambition, of spending she considered excessive and of an insufficient contribution. The court, which gives very little credibility to her testimony, rejects all of her criticisms:
- his modest income is explained by his dismissal, which occurred before the marriage, and by a forced career change; she married him knowing full well where things stood;
- he paid the contribution she set herself, dipping into his RRSPs when needed, and kept paying it after the mortgage was fully repaid, which covered his share of upkeep and renovations;
- the Costco purchases included the couple’s food and household items, even if a small portion was sometimes given to his parents; as for replacing his computer, needed among other things to prepare the couple’s tax returns, and buying three phones, one of which he gave to her, these were “normal and justified” expenses;
- the couple’s disagreement over the neighbourhood in which to buy a house is a fault on neither side.
The judge also points out several contradictions in her testimony. For example, she claimed to get by in English at best, before admitting that she holds a bachelor’s degree in English-to-French translation. The division will therefore be equal.
How much of a multi-unit building is the family residence?
Another interesting question: what portion of the building constitutes the family residence? She argued for one third, since the couple occupied only the ground floor of a building that also had an upstairs unit and a rented “bachelor” in the basement. The court notes that identifying the family residence is a question of fact, based on how the premises were actually used. It sets the family residence at 50% of the building, namely the ground floor and half of the basement, which the couple used in part for storage. Taking into account her undivided share and the value accrued during the marriage, the court sets the amount she owes him on this account at $14,093.
Most of the amount, however, comes from the pension plans. During the marriage, she accrued $210,414 in her employer pension plan, compared with $45,456.56 for him. She therefore owes him $82,478.72. Added to this are $7,237.13 for the RRSPs, to be transferred by tax-free rollover, meaning with no immediate tax consequences, as well as an equal division of the earnings registered with the Québec Pension Plan. In all, more than $100,000, with interest from the 2015 separation.
Refusing to disclose your documents is costly
He also claimed $30,000 for abuse of procedure and serious breaches in the conduct of the proceedings. The judge dismisses most of that claim. Turning down a settlement offer in mediation or at a settlement conference is not an abuse unless it is motivated by bad faith, and the content of those negotiations is confidential in any event. Changing lawyers several times is not a fault in itself either. However, she repeatedly refused to disclose her financial documents, to the point that he had to resort to a subpoena to obtain them. That obstruction earns her an order to pay $2,000 under article 342 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.C.P.).
Why this decision stands out
It illustrates a reversal that many spouses do not anticipate. She was the one who insisted on separation as to property, to protect herself from a husband she considered financially vulnerable. Yet at the divorce, she is the one who must pay, because her pension plan, which is part of the family patrimony, grew much more than his during the marriage.
The judgment also confirms how reluctant the courts are to order an unequal division. Passing judgment on a spouse’s lifestyle, career ambition or spending habits is not enough: an economic fault that compromised the family patrimony must be proven. Some argue that such a strict approach may seem harsh for the spouse who carried most of the expenses during certain years. In our view, the law is designed precisely to prevent every divorce from turning into a trial of the couple’s married life.
Finally, the decision is a reminder of the cost of waiting: separated in 2015, the parties only get an answer in 2026. Interest runs from the separation, while the additional indemnity runs only from the 2024 application, as the judge found that both parties must bear the consequences of their delay in acting.
Key takeaways
Separation as to property does not protect everything. Family residences, furniture, vehicles, pension plans, RRSPs and Québec Pension Plan earnings accrued during the marriage are, in principle, divided equally.
Unequal division is exceptional. A genuine economic fault, such as wasting property or acting in bad faith, must be proven. A modest income, a less ambitious career or questionable spending choices are not enough.
Each spouse contributes according to their means. Contributing less because you earn less is not a fault. Keep records of your contribution: transfers, invoices, RRSP withdrawals.
Disclose your financial documents. Obstruction can lead to an order to reimburse part of the other party’s legal fees.
Do not wait years after the separation. Interest builds up, evidence fades and the conflict drags on.
Further reading
See also our columns on property division agreements signed at separation and changing your mind, on a spouse who sold his ex’s building without her knowledge and lost his share of the acquests, on the partition of the family residence and on the compensatory allowance in a divorce.
This column is published for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Because every situation is unique, you should consult a lawyer for advice tailored to your own case. Feel free to contact Virtulex avocats to discuss your situation.
William Desrochers, Attorney, Virtulex avocats — www.virtulexavocats.com
Reference: Droit de la famille — 261532, 2026 QCCS 3670, Superior Court of Québec, District of Montréal, the Honourable Stéphane Lacoste, J.S.C., September 30, 2026 — read the judgment on CanLII (in French).
Other decision mentioned: M.T. v. J.-Y.T., 2008 SCC 50.
